Most business cases die the moment finance asks one question: whose number is that? If nobody on the customer side will put their name to it, the case is dead. So is your deal.
The 700% spreadsheet
Picture the deal. Your Champion loves you. You spend a weekend on an ROI model. Nine benefits, industry benchmarks, a three-year view. 700% ROI.
Your Champion forwards it to the CFO. The CFO asks one question. "Where did this number come from?"
Silence. The deal goes quiet, and your forecast takes the hit.
Nobody lied. The numbers were yours, not theirs.
Buyers want the case. Few sellers can build it.
66% of buyers say ROI and business cases are critical to their decision. 16% of sellers can make an effective ROI case. That gap is where deals go to die.
More benchmarks won't close it. Building the case with the customer will. An analysis of 2,960 opportunities found that building the value case with the customer raised the odds of winning 3.4x. The ROI figure on its own didn't strongly correlate with winning.
I'd rather see three lines the customer signed than nine benchmarks they've never seen.
Start with their Metrics
A BVA should never start from a blank sheet. By the time you build one, each stakeholder should already have agreed their Metrics with you: their number, a baseline, a target and an owner.
The BVA takes those Metrics, stacks them up and puts a price on them. If a stakeholder hasn't agreed a Metric yet, they don't get a line. Go back to discovery.
One line per stakeholder
Company-wide numbers have no owner. So build one line per stakeholder. What the pain means for them. Their number. What it's worth a year. What every month of waiting costs. Then ask them to sign it.
Now when the CFO asks whose number it is, the answer is a name in their own business.
Put Cost of Inaction next to ROI
ROI tells the Economic Buyer what they could gain. Cost of Inaction tells them what every month of waiting is costing them right now. Show both, side by side.
Plenty of deals never lose to a competitor. They lose to doing nothing, to a good-enough option, or to the budget moving to another project. A monthly number is how you out-prioritize all three.
Earn the BVA
A BVA is a lot of work, for you and for your customer. So earn it. No Implicated Pain, no agreed Metrics, no Economic Buyer, no Champion willing to build it with you? You're not ready. Close the gaps first, or qualify out.
And if the math doesn't work (payback past 12 months, or benefits under 1.2 times the cost), walk. That's the BVA doing its job early. You get your time back for the deals you can win.
Keep it alive after signature
The signed lines become success criteria in your Go Live Plan. After go-live, you prove them. At renewal, you walk in with the value your customer signed off on.
So, on your biggest deal right now: could every stakeholder tell you their number, and would they sign it?



Customer Stories
NAMIE
Metrics
Economic Buyer
Decision Criteria
Decision Process
Paper Process
Implicate the Pain
Champion
Competition










Core: the play builds this element throughout